Nutrisystem vs Factor vs Optavia (Trilivy) in 2026: What You Eat, What It Costs and Who Each One Suits

Last updated: October 16, 2026. This article is general information, not medical advice. Talk to your doctor or a registered dietitian before starting a weight loss program, especially a low-calorie plan, or if you have diabetes, another health condition, are pregnant or have a history of disordered eating. Some links may be affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you, and it never affects how we compare programs.

Short answer: Nutrisystem is the best value if you want a complete weight loss plan delivered, with most of your day’s food in the box. Factor is the better choice if you want fresh, ready-made meals and can plan the rest of your eating yourself. Optavia, renamed Trilivy in 2026, has the strictest structure and a personal coach, but its main plan is very low in calories and worth discussing with your doctor first.

These three are often compared, but they aren’t the same kind of product. Below you’ll see what a day of eating looks like on each, what a week really costs once you count what’s left for you to buy, and how the support and safety compare.

Optavia is now Trilivy

In July 2026, Medifast, the company behind Optavia, renamed the program Trilivy and repositioned it around metabolic health rather than weight loss alone. The core of the program carries over: packaged meal replacements called Fuelings, structured plans such as the 5 & 1, and independent coaches. Some products are still sold under the Optavia name during the transition, so you may see both names. We use “Optavia” in this article because it’s the name most people still know.

What a typical day looks like

The quickest way to see the difference is to follow one day on each plan.

NutrisystemFactorOptavia 5 & 1
BreakfastNutrisystem breakfast item, plus fruit or dairy you addYour own, unless you order breakfast add-onsA Fueling (shake, bar or similar)
LunchNutrisystem lunch, plus vegetables you addA Factor meal, heated in a couple of minutesA Fueling
DinnerNutrisystem entrée, plus vegetables or protein you addA Factor mealA “Lean & Green” meal you cook: lean protein and vegetables
SnacksOne Nutrisystem snack, plus snacks you choose within the guidelinesYour ownThree more Fuelings spread through the day
Who decides portionsThe program, for the delivered foodYou, using each meal’s nutrition labelThe program

Put simply: Nutrisystem decides most of your day, Optavia decides almost all of it, and Factor only decides the meals you order.

What a week really costs

Per-day prices are misleading here, because each service covers a different share of your food. This table shows one week, using regular prices rather than first-order discounts, and what you still need to buy yourself.

OptionListed priceAbout per weekStill on you
Nutrisystem, 5 days a weekAbout $365 per 4 weeksAbout $91Fresh add-ons, plus all food on the other 2 days
Nutrisystem, 7 days a weekAbout $420 per 4 weeksAbout $105Fresh add-ons such as vegetables, fruit and dairy
Factor, 14 meals (lunch and dinner)About $11.49 per meal, plus $13.99 shippingAbout $175Breakfast and snacks
Factor, 6 mealsAbout $13.99 per meal, plus $13.99 shippingAbout $98Most of your week
Optavia 5 & 1 kitAbout $480 for 140 Fuelings (4 weeks)About $120Seven home-cooked Lean & Green meals

A worked example shows how the extras change the picture. Say you spend about $50 a week on the fresh food each plan asks you to add. Your week then costs roughly $155 on Nutrisystem’s 7-day plan and $170 on Optavia’s 5 & 1. Factor’s 14-meal box is already about $175 before you buy any breakfasts or snacks.

So Factor costs the most if you want it to cover most of your eating. It becomes reasonable when you only replace a few meals a week, such as weekday lunches.

All three run large first-order discounts. Base your decision on the price you’ll pay from the second order onward, because that’s what the program really costs.

Which is easiest to lose weight on?

Nutrisystem is built for it. You get portion-controlled food for most of the day and simple rules for what to add, so you don’t need to count anything. It also has specific plans, including one for people with type 2 diabetes. If you have diabetes, use it only with your doctor’s approval, since changes in eating can affect blood sugar and medication needs.

Factor isn’t a weight loss program on its own. It offers a lower-calorie menu with meals under 550 calories, plus high-protein and keto options, and every meal has a full nutrition label. Whether you lose weight depends on what you eat the rest of the day.

Optavia has the most structure, which some people find freeing: few decisions, clear rules. But the structure comes from a very low calorie intake, which brings us to the next point.

Is Optavia’s 5 & 1 plan safe?

The 5 & 1 plan provides roughly 800 to 1,000 calories a day, which is much less than most adults need. Plans this low can cause fatigue, muscle loss and nutrient gaps if they aren’t supervised, and they aren’t suitable for everyone. Talk to your doctor before starting, especially if you take medication for diabetes or blood pressure, since doses may need adjusting.

Optavia also offers less restrictive plans for slower weight loss and for maintenance. If you like the program’s structure but not the calorie level, ask about those.

Food quality: fresh meals vs packaged food

Factor’s meals are fresh, fully cooked and never frozen, with a menu that changes weekly. Nutrisystem relies on shelf-stable food, with frozen entrées on higher-priced plans. Optavia’s Fuelings are processed meal replacements by design.

Fresh doesn’t automatically mean lighter, though. Some Factor meals are high in sodium or saturated fat, so check the label of each dish. On every plan, the fresh vegetables, fruit and whole grains you add are what fill the nutritional gaps, and they also build the habits you’ll need after the program ends.

Coaching: what you’re actually getting

Optavia pairs you with a personal coach, and many members find that daily accountability motivating. Keep in mind that these coaches are independent sellers who earn a commission on what their clients buy. They’re usually not dietitians or medical professionals.

Nutrisystem gives you its NuMi app for tracking, and it advertises coaching by chat or phone. Factor is self-guided: you get the meals and the labels, and the planning is up to you.

Which is easiest to stop?

This matters more than people expect, because the goal is to keep the weight off once the deliveries end.

  • Cancelling: Factor runs week to week, and you can skip, pause or cancel before each weekly cutoff. Nutrisystem and Optavia use recurring auto-delivery; you can cancel, but check the cutoff date and any first-order conditions before you sign up.
  • Going back to normal eating: Factor is the easiest, because it’s closest to normal meals. With Nutrisystem and Optavia, plan the transition in advance: both have maintenance phases, and gradually swapping in more of your own meals can help you avoid regaining weight.

Who each one suits

  • Choose Nutrisystem if you want a complete plan that tells you what to eat most of the day, at the lowest weekly cost of the three, and you don’t mind packaged food.
  • Choose Factor if you care most about fresh, good food, already know roughly what to eat, and want to replace only some meals.
  • Consider Optavia only if you want strict rules and a daily coach, and you’ve talked to your doctor about the calorie level.

Skip all three if you have a history of disordered eating, are pregnant or breastfeeding, or have a condition that needs a specific medical diet. A registered dietitian can build a plan for you instead.

If you’d rather have coaching without buying your food from the program, see our guide to the best online weight loss programs.

Common questions

Is Nutrisystem or Factor better for weight loss?

Nutrisystem is designed as a weight loss program, with portion-controlled food for most of the day. Factor can support weight loss if you choose its lower-calorie meals and plan the rest of your eating carefully.

Which is cheaper, Nutrisystem or Optavia?

Nutrisystem’s 7-day plan costs about $105 a week against about $120 for Optavia’s 5 & 1 kit. Both need fresh food on top, and Optavia also needs one home-cooked meal a day.

Is Trilivy the same as Optavia?

Yes. Trilivy is the new name Medifast gave Optavia in July 2026. The Fuelings, structured plans and coach model continue, with some products renamed or updated.

How we compared

We reviewed each company’s current plans, menus and pricing, and compared them on what you eat in a day, total weekly cost, food quality, calorie structure, support, flexibility and safety. We don’t recommend any plan based on how fast it promises weight loss. Prices change often, and we update this page when they do.

Sources

About the author

Written by Alex Morgan: I evaluate meal programs by reviewing their menus, nutritional information, variety, pricing, preparation time, and ease of use. I also research customer feedback and available evidence to understand how well each program fits different lifestyles and dietary preferences. My goal is to provide honest, easy-to-understand reviews that help readers compare options and make informed decisions about their eating habits.

This content is for informational purposes only and does not replace professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment.

2 thoughts on “Nutrisystem vs Factor vs Optavia (Trilivy) in 2026: What You Eat, What It Costs and Who Each One Suits”

  1. Pingback: Best Online Weight Loss Programs of 2026: 5 Picks Compared by Cost and Support – weightprogramguide.com

  2. Pingback: Meal Kits vs Prepared Meals vs Grocery Delivery: What Healthy Eating Really Costs in 2026 – weightprogramguide.com

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top